IAC Forums
Chew the Fat! => Sleight of Hand => Topic started by: veredk on January 27, 2022, 10:47:21 PM
-
In this auction: none vulnerable, p, 3 !D, 3 !S/ 5 !D, X is this double for penalty? The doubler's hand: !ST, !HQ62, !DQT98, !CJT652.
Would there be a different meaning to a double if the opening bid was 1 !D not 3 !D?
Thank you, Vered
-
A big fat WELCOME! to our forur, Vered!! qucik answer to you question is "yes--they are different"... long answer about what to do is item #2 on my list.....(WHAT msc problem is this related to
??? i grovel , if this is too obvious)
-
Pass - 3D - 3S - 5D
?
I prefer a double here to be takeout, length in the two unbid suits
and some spade tolerance. With the actual hand I would pass and
hope for a plus score, maybe glad that we're not in 4S since I have
only a singleton spade. The "theory" is that when the opponents
preempt the bidding it is more useful to say "I have a little something
and maybe we can make something at the five level" - rather than to
increase a +50 score to +100.
I'm not sure about the second part of the question:
Pass - 1D - 1S (?) - 5D
?
While I still prefer a double to be for takeout if partner could only
overcall at the one level maybe you could make a case for double to
be penalty. To be consistent and unless I'd discussed it with pard I'd
stick with takeout. If pard has no defence and declarer ends up with
only one diamond loser why do I think we can defeat 5D with my actual
hand, as provided?
Hope that helps,
Oliver
-
Thank you Oliver